Last Thursday, I put myself in a pretty awful situation. It was about 4:30pm, I was hungry…and then I went on Pinterest.
You know how they say you should never go grocery shopping when you’re hungry? Yeah, well you should never go on Pinterest when you’re hungry either.
My mouth watered as I browsed through each recipe, with my only saving grace being that most of the recipes either called for ingredients I didn’t have, or would have taken more time than I wanted to deal with.
But then…I came across Gracie’s recipe for Cake Batter Blondies and all bets were off. I remembered having come across that recipe quite a ways back, but I had totally forgotten about them up until that point.
I already knew that I didn’t have any sprinkles on hand, so the fun “funfetti” look would not have been possible, and what’s the point in that? Then, I came across another variation that she made using Nutella and I realized that that was something I could work with.
Because I didn’t have any Nutella on hand…but I DID have some white chocolate peanut butter…and man oh man did that sound like a delicious combo. Turns out, it is not only delicious…
it is dangerously delicious.
White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake Batter Bars
(Inspired by Gracie’s Nutella Cake Batter Blondies)
Ingredients:
- 1 box yellow cake mix
- 1/2 cup white chocolate peanut butter, melted*
- 1/4 egg substitute (or 1 egg, beaten)
- 1 tablespoon canola oil
- 1/3 cup skim milk
- 1/2 cup white chocolate chips (optional)
*any regular peanut butter would taste just as good, too!
Directions:
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. In a small bowl whisk together egg substitute, oil, and peanut butter. Add cake mix (and chips, if using) to the wet mixture and combine (batter will be very thick). Slowly add the milk and stir until just combined.
Place batter in an 8×8 pan sprayed with nonstick cooking spray. Bake for 22-25 minutes or just until the edges turn golden. Allow to cool completely (at least 30 minutes) before cutting – the center will otherwise be pretty gooey!
I’d be willing to bet that these would taste phenomenal if they were topped with some White Chocolate Buttercream or Fudgy Frosting, but I just couldn’t bring myself to do it…
I already did enough damage on them without making them even more delicious. ![]()







Welcome to Sweet Tooth, Sweet Life! I'm Courtney, a 28-year old personal trainer living in Upstate, NY. I enjoy all things related to food, fitness, and fashion, as well as feeding my huge sweet tooth. To find out a little bit more about the girl behind the blog, check out my



{ 37 comments… read them below or add one }
Those look incredible!!! I am with you- no Pinterest when hungry!! It might be even more dangerous than the grocery store.
Carol @ Lucky Zucca recently posted..Half-Marathon Training Review: Week 8
PS- I totally pinned these…
Carol @ Lucky Zucca recently posted..Half-Marathon Training Review: Week 8
is it bad i am salivating over these yet i am allergic to peanuts?! haha!
Oh my goodness! These look amazing. I definitely want to try baking these.
Hope @ With A Side Of Hope recently posted..My Saturday With Bethenny Frankel!!!…
Those look sinfully delicious!
Frosting would almost overkill- I bet they are sooo good by themselves!
Carrie @ Lift Eat Repeat recently posted..Mind Over Matter
These might be my first Easter morning indulgence.
Claire @ Live and Love to Eat recently posted..Weekend Worth Repeating
OMG! That is all…
Elle recently posted..The Fit Executive… Review and e-book Giveaway
Oh wow, those look amazing!
Caroline @ After Dinner Dance recently posted..Chinese Hot Pot Dinner
I just tried Gracie’s cake batter blondies a month or so ago and LOVEDDD them (so much that I know better than to make them again anytime soon haha). Trying it with the white chocolate pb…genius and looks awesome!!
Love this! I was looking for a dessert to bring to a family dinner Wednesday. I think I might substitute sugar-free white chocolate pudding since I have a box screaming to be used. Can’t wait to try these!
Lauren @ Call Me Mrs. Rapp recently posted..Chicken with Creamy Mustard Sauce
okay, it’s sick how quickly I just mentally perused my pantry for these ingredients and starred that recipe. you made them look so goshdarn good.
if I have a problem, then so be it. I want these in my belly. stat.
Alyssa @ Life of bLyss recently posted..What Would You Do?
My mouth is watering looking at these!
Melissa @ Some Sugar Added recently posted..Living Room Leg Workout
Yum! These look fantastic! I’ve actually made Gracie’s cake batter blondies & they’re to die for!
Erica @ For the Sake of Cake recently posted..Sunday Dinner
I can’t believe I have all the ingredients down to the yellow cake box!
I just calculated the calories at 150 when cut into 12 servings.
Will make it IMMEDIATELY right after I finish my black bean brownies.
P.S. Silly questions: unsweetened vanilla almond milk instead of skim milk is okay right?
Oh my goodness I am making these tonight!!
Now I know what to make with my box of cake mix!!
Bookmarked! Or pinned. Either way, I’m making these.
Alaina recently posted..Ole! Mexican Grill
oh my goodness, i can imagine how dangerously delicious these babies are!
i saw the original version of these the other day on lindsay’s blog (in sweetness & in health) as well, and i thought they sounded amazing! i’m loving your version as well… i LOVE white choc peanut butter!
Ashley @ My Food ‘N’ Fitness Diaries recently posted..Staying Motivated {Giveaway}
Oooooooooooohhhh, if I switch out the white chocolate peanut butter for regular peanut butter, I can eat these during Lent. Yayyyyyyy!
These look awfully tasty.
Shannon recently posted..Snow, snow, snow and a quick thought on Leap Day
I agree… Pinterest is dangerous when hungry!!! Those look amazing though, gonna have to try them out!
Alyssa @ fit and fun in third recently posted..Rising Above Negativity
I wish I didn’t see this post, lol. Now I want to make this!!!
Liz @ Tip Top Shape recently posted..Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
oh my goodness these look DELICIOUS!! i’m drooling right on my keyboard.
and i’m totally with ya on the Pinterest thing – my “recipes to try” board is full of sweet treats and creamy pasta dishes because i always find myself on there when i’m hungry!!
Julianna @ Julianna Bananna recently posted..Scenes from L.A.
Oh my goodness – I automatically love anything involving cake batter! Add white chocolate and PB to the mix? Sounds like heaven
Michelle (Better with Berries) recently posted..Blueberry Oat Bites
These look SO good! This will definitely be the next baking project!
Katie recently posted..So ready for the weekend.
Oh my…Oh my, my, my…
I think I need to pretend I didn’t see this recipe…
Katie @ Talk Less, Say More recently posted..Music Monday // Norah Jones
Man oh Man these look ridiculously good!!!!!! I just pinned it to try this weekend!
Lauren @ Fun, Fit and FAbulous recently posted..Lean Legs March Week 3 Exercises
I’ve only made the original cake batter blondies but they are AMAZING!!! Addictive is an understatement…
Jessica @ The Process of Healing recently posted..Sometimes…
These look amazing! Dangerous to have in my house!! I’d eat them all!! All I tell ya!!
Jennifer @ Peanut Butter and Peppers recently posted..Corned Beef and Cabbage
You and your PB!!
Talia @ Bite Size Wellness recently posted..Spa Addict: $50 Treatments for your Health from Spa Week
Holy yum! I love peanut butter…I need to try this!
Caroline recently posted..Monday Recap
uh YUM!!! You beat me to the peanut butter, miss thang
haha. Love the idea of using white chocolate peanut butter…must get on this ASAP!
p.s. long time no talk…hope all is well! XOXO G
Gracie recently posted..because it’s my birthday, duh.
Haha, girl, you are a genius.
Yes, it’s been too long! Hope all is well with you too! xoxo
I’m totally making these… Like tonight. !
Rebecca recently posted..Little Recap
I made these tonight and they were AMAZING. I have never tasted anything like them before. It’s a very cool recipe. I expected it to brownie-ish for some reason, and it wasn’t….a pleasant surprise, however! Thanks for sharing this!
wow, these look amazing Courtney. I love that you didn’t put too much additional fat, like butter and oil. Good stuff!
honeywhatscooking recently posted..Friday’s Favorite Things – 3.16.12
AHHHH. i just made these- omg SO good!!!
thanks!!
i bought white chocolate pb JUST to make these! did you make yours with the white chocolate chips or without?
mandee recently posted..Dark Chocolate Raspberry Kiss Cakes
I don’t think I did…haha, I had to think about that! If I had them on hand I would have, but I think I was out at the time
{ 3 trackbacks }