Alternate title: When You Forget to Tell Stitch Fix You’re Pregnant
Whoops. It was unfortunate that I received my reminder email that a fix would be on its way soon on Christmas Eve. Since I was a bit preoccupied that day, I don’t recall ever having seen it. Then last Friday, I received an email saying “Your fix is on its way!” and I said, oh crap. I hadn’t updated my profile to notify them that I’m pregnant (and would likely prefer items from their maternity line at this point)!
That said, I anticipated the fix being a total bust but, in fact, I actually found a few really cute items and a couple I’m even considering keeping. Who woulda thought?!
In case you’re new to Stitch Fix and how it works, you can read all about it in my first post about the service, HERE.
So here’s a look! And maybe one of these months I’ll actually have some pictures hung on our bedroom walls and maybe even have some paint up on there, too. Someday… 
LIVERPOOL Mira Skinny Jean – $88.00
Denim with elastic waistband: similar, similar, similar, similar, similar (<—love!)
When I saw that jeans were included in my fix, I chuckled out loud and almost didn’t even bother trying them on. But then I read the note from my stylist, and she mentioned how they have an elastic waistband. Say whaaaaat?!
So I gave them a shot and, sure enough, they actually worked! I’m currently able to wear them comfortably by folding down the waistband under my bump, and they actually stay put better than any other jeans I have right now. They are a little snug in the sides, but I’m wondering if it’s worth it, because I can absolutely see myself wearing these for as long as pregnancy will allow, and then (hopefully) postpartum.
But seriously…jeans with an elastic waistband? A+++ in my book! Now to decide whether or not to keep them…
ARATTA Lebray Button Down Top – $64.00
similar, similar, similar (<—love!)
I’m a total sucker for a cute, plaid, button down shirt. And as soon as I put this one on, I knew it was a keeper. The nice thing about button downs is that I can wear it no matter how big my belly grows, thanks to being able to wear it open. For now, I can still button it closed, but it’s a big snug. Either way, I’m in love!
PAPERMOON Cuvee Crochet Back Knit Top – $54.00
similar (<—super cute!), similar, similar
I really love the detailing on the back of this top, but the fit just wasn’t flattering right now, and I likely wouldn’t even be able to wear it a month from now. So since I probably wouldn’t get the chance to wear this top until next fall, I decided it wasn’t worth it to keep that long without wearing. Return.
MOON & SKY Modena Crochet Hem Knit Top – $58.00
This top was cute and theory and I’d be interested to see how it fit without a growing belly. But, again, since it doesn’t work for me now, and likely wouldn’t work for a while, there was no sense in keeping it. Also, I guess I probably should have worn a different color bra with that one. Whoops. Return.
LOVEAPPELLA Evie Draw String Funnel Neck Sweatshirt – $64.00
I’ve had this sweatshirt pinned to my Pinterest board for a while now, so I was excited to see it this fix. However, when I tried it on, it wasn’t quite the material I was expecting, and the fit wasn’t exactly what I was hoping either. I would have liked it to be a bit longer, along with the sleeves, too. You guys know how I am about my longer sleeves with comfy sweaters/tops!
Since it didn’t pass the sleeve test and the material was a bit weird, I decided not to keep it. Return.
Well, there’s a look at my January Stitch Fix! Three returns, one keep, and one maybe. I’ve already updated my profile so that my next fix features some maternity items, so I’m excited to see what comes next.
So what do you guys think?! Have you tried Stitch Fix lately?
I just got THE BEST coat from Stitch Fix. Perfect for our super cold upstate New York weather!
Those jeans look great and I really love the plaid shirt too!
I always have the pro8with long enough sleeves too! What gives?
The elastic waist jeans are brilliant! I imagine they will be perfect for that postpartum in between stage!
Get the jeans!!! They look super fabulous on you and I totally think you’ll get some great wear out of them (even if it’s only a little now and most of it later postpartum!)
That Crochet Hem Knit Top is adorable and I think it looks great on you now!
I got the exact same jeans last month. I LOVE the elastic waistband! However, the color came off the jeans the first couple times I wore them (so much so that my hands turned blue)–even after washing. So, they are a slightly lighter color now. Also, a couple of the grommets have fallen off around the pockets. I love the way they fit, but I feel like the quality leaves a little to be desired for a pair of jeans that cost $88.
I have two pairs of the Liverpool Mira skinny jeans from Stitch Fix and they are AMAZING. I am not (and have never been) pregnant and I wear these pants at least once or twice every week! Best jeggings EVER! So cute and comfortable. Keep them. You will not regret it ;)
i wish i hadn’t read Nicki’s comment above, i was going to say 100% to the jeans. They look great on you! If you keep them, i would suggest washing them inside out and by themselves for the first few washes. i had the same issues with a pair from gap. I may join stitch fix just for my own pair of elastic jeans!
Hi Courtney! For what it’s worth, I did the same thing when I received a pair of skinny jeans with an elastic waist. But, I tried them on and fell in love. To this day, they’re my absolute favorite pair to wear. Hands down! haha. I bet they’d be great for a preggo belly… at least for now. ;) Have a great weekend!
Good to know! Thanks lady, I decided to keep them!
Cute stuff! I noticed your date is 2015 and not 2016 ;)
Ohhh, poo! I even remember making a mental note to put 2016 when I did it! Ahh well…
I say keep the jeans!! Haha. I hate jeans, so the only pair I have has an elastic waistband and I’m not even pregnant … I just don’t like normal jeans. ;)
Keep the jeans!!!
The jeans look great on you. I’d say keep them. And I too received that same plaid top in my fix (got it on Christmas Eve too). I love it.
i’m a total sucker for a plaid shirt and can never have too many! Stitch Fix is def not for me, but i like reading your posts about them and seeing what they send.
Aw you look so good in all the clothes, and that little bump is soo cute and jealous you can still fit into normal jeans, I was busting into maternity jeans by 12 weeks….lol…maybe you could keep them all for the 4th trimester..lol.
Keep the jeans!!! They look great! I wish you would’ve kept those 1st 2 tops, too – they were super cute on you, & you could still wear them after the baby is born…
I say a huge yes to the plaid shirt! So freaking adorable on you! That sweatshirt is working for you as well. You look good in everything Courtney!
I decided to get one stitch fix during my pregnancy and I am so glad I did! The only bad thing is that I kept all of the items which I’ve never done before. I requested that no items be actual maternity, but that they be items that would work for now and after pregnancy. I got the cutest vest, jacket, purse, and a couple of long tops. I have been disappointed in my last few fixes but Emily nailed it this time! That bump is looking cute!
What do you think about a service similar to Stitch Fix but with pre-owned clothes? Where the average cost of an item is around $15-$20 instead of $55.00?
I’d definitely be interested in hearing more!